Lindberg: Thoughts on Dice-K and Red Sox

By Andy Lindberg

I really do like Daisuke Matsuzaka.  I writhe in agony whenever I watch him pitch, imagining walk upon walk until the pitch count hits 100 in the fourth inning and whatever batter he has the misfortune of grooving one to finally uncorks a big fly and sends Matsuzaka forth into the gloomy musk of the dugout hallway.  That imagination turns to reality fairly often, it seems.  But I still like him.

Struck from the memories are the excellent starts Matsuzaka has had in a Boston uniform.  But once he established himself as a tedious, meticulous painter of the area just outside the strike zone, there was no recovering in the eyes of the Boston faithful.

So forgotten are his [18-3] 2008 campaign, his rookie year World Series win, and his .613 winning percentage.  What stands out to most of us are his sole complete game, which came in 2007, his 94 walks in 2008 that he somehow managed to pitch around, and the legend that was Matsuzaka well before he took the hill for Boston four years ago.

But maybe therein lies the problem, and maybe Matsuzaka himself is the perfect metaphor for these 2011 Boston Red Sox.  Predicted to be unstoppable, personified as an unrelenting, massacring force capable of inexplicable damage to be thrust upon any and all opponents.  A force so brilliant and earth shattering, fans would be reduced to tears at the sheer beauty and terrible power that would be displayed before them in the confines of venerable Fenway Park.

The 2011 Red Sox won the World Series before they even took the field, just as Matsuzaka won three Cy Young awards and threw two perfect games with the mysterious gyro ball before ever throwing a pitch in practice for the Red Sox.

Yet, upon taking the field, we realize through all the unnecessary, ill-advised, and uninformed hype that both entities here are inexplicably, fundamentally flawed.  The 2011 Red Sox are a new team with a new lineup and overhauled bullpen.  Players are not familiar with their spots in the batting order because the order is drastically different than it ever has been and it has yet to remain slightly consistent to this point in the season.  The pitching staff is aging and there is no clear-cut positive force in the clubhouse to make things as loose as they were when Kevin Millar was around.

Matsuzaka comes from a league where the transition as a pitcher is much more difficult that that of a hitter.  The ball is smaller in Japan and therefore, theoretically, easier to control.  The subtlest differences to the creatures of strict mentality and habit that are pitchers make or break performance.

In eight years for the Seibu Lions, Matsuzaka racked up an impressive [108-60] record with ERA’s that never went above 3.97 and reached as low as 2.13, a feat achieved his final year in the league.  In fact, his ERA in his final four years with the lions went from 2.83 in 2003, to 2.90 in ‘04, 2.30 in ‘05, and finally, 2.13 in 2006.  The progression he was making was undeniable as was the logic to pursue a career in the be all and end all of Major League Baseball in America.

But the differences, or the pressure, or the way the Red Sox changed his entire approach to pitching instead of letting Matsuzaka do what had worked so well for him in Japan, hindered his progression as a number one or two Major League starting pitcher.

The 2011 Red Sox have transitioned from bridge team to on-paper juggernaut, but the pressure, or the lineup differences, or the clubhouse differences have hindered what worked so well for these players individually before.

But aside from the complete meltdown of Matsuzaka on Monday, I still like him.  Although maybe not as a top-three starter.  And I still like the 2011 Red Sox.  I’ll like them even if they don’t win another game all year.  They’re my team.

But maybe the lesson here, if there is any, is that in looking at the grand history of the wonderful game of baseball; don’t count your chickens before they hatch.

2 thoughts on “Lindberg: Thoughts on Dice-K and Red Sox”

  1. I’ve always liked him too. He has that innocent wide-eyed thing that’s just hilarious when he strikes them out, and heartwrenching when he doesn’t… but it’s time to cut our losses.

    1. That’s an issue the Sox cannot afford to think about at this point. I know how frustrating it is, but the sad fact is the Red Sox don’t have as much starting depth as one might think. Trading him is out of the question. His trade value is so low the Sox would almost certainly have to include a Major League-ready bat in any deal. Jacoby Ellsbury and Ryan Kalish would be the two names included in those talks, and that would be foolish to consider. The other issue is the Red Sox would almost certainly have to pay out the rest of Matsuzaka’s salary. Michael Bowden has not seen enough ML time nor has he progressed as well as Boston thought. Felix Doubront is the best suited for the role, but due to his short spring, he does not yet possess the stamina to step in. Anthony Ranaudo is highly promising, but he’s in single-A ball and it as least two years away from making a significant contribution of any kind to the big club. For at least the next three or four starts, the Red Sox have to deal with Matsuzaka. I believe they’re thinking of skipping his next start, and are hoping he throws as effectively as he did in his final three spring starts. Time will tell on this one, but his time is rapidly running out.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.